Hmm I miss my blog! Sorry poor blog. I still talk to you in my head I just rarely get the chance to write anything down.
On a blog topic, RIP my HTC Wildfire, Jan 2011 - Jan 2016. Not a bad run.
A brief history of the phone: I bought the red one despite the guy in the shop being confused about why I didn't want grey (?!),
almost died trying to get Hebrew to work on it a couple of years after that, put up with an ever increasing list of ailments (broked screen, replacement screen gathering increasing amounts of dust under it, any number of apps refusing to install or slowing to a halt, power button only liking to be pressed a certain way, camera getting so scuffed pictures were uselessly blurry, USB port getting finicky about unfamiliar USB cables, etc etc) until one day around Christmas I dropped it for the hundredth time and it made a very...
final type of noise.
I picked it up expecting to see cracks, was momentarily relieved to find none, and then subsequently immediately disappointed to find the touch screen no longer responded on about 30% of its area. I survived the following couple of weeks mostly using the joystick which I was suddenly very grateful for the existence of.
It was time. I looked into possible replacements. My requirements were, in descending order of importance:
- That thing you've heard me rant about 200+ times, i.e. 'small enough to fit in a women's front pocket and still allow you the use of your limbs' and/or 'usable one handed by a me', i.e. 'about the same size as my current phone' (106mm)
- Sturdy and up to date enough to last several years.
- Screen, OS, camera, battery, and other such specs - no specific thresholds for any of them, but the moar better, the better. It would be awesome to take great photos, run the latest apps, only charge it on a full moon, etc.
- Budget not too much of an issue as I'm hoping it will also last 5 years or so so am OK sinking some cash into it if it helps to get my need met.
I quickly realised I had to give up on requirement 1 in its original form. Phones around that size technically did exist, such as the
Galaxy Young (109mm, £50) but they were so extremely low end as to be laughable, i.e. you are literally pulling my leg, there is no way I am buying a phone with the exact same screen resolution and RAM as my current one, which I would like to point out was a mid-range model when it came out in 2010 and only runs at all because I've found workarounds for everything. I'd basically be buying my current phone but without the physical damage, which in all honestly, I came quite close to doing in moments of particular frustration, but wasn't exactly a path I'd be pleased about. Especially after fantasising about having a decent camera on my phone and playing music on it and possibly games?!
Taking a step up in size allowed for quite a step up in specs. Looking online I narrowed down my choices to:
- Galaxy S5 mini (2014, 131mm, 8MP camera, 1.5 GB RAM etc etc, £200)
- Z3 Compact (2014, 127mm, 2GB RAM, stupid-megapixel camera, shiny, waterproof, etc, £250)
- Z5 Compact (2015, same size and similar specs to the Z3 but EXTRA shinier and newer, £360)
Other brands didn't do mini versions of their 'normal' phones, or they were significantly bigger or crapper than these two, which stood out as the best of the lot. (I excluded dubious Chinese phones from my search).
But honestly I wasn't thrilled with any of my options. The Sony Compacts were winning the race, thanks to being that little bit smaller (which, seriously, I wasn't sure to what extent I was being I-know-what-I-like vs simply obstinate, but every single millimetre hurt and felt like it might be the tipping point between 'can work' and 'won't actually work, I am now seriously contemplating getting custom pockets in every pair of trousers I own', and if you're in that territory, it's time to just get an average sized phone and a handbag to carry it around in). And they were a lot shinier specs wise, unlike the Galaxies which seriously downgrade their flagship phones for the Mini versions, which I obviously resent. And I came into this willing to pay decent moneys for the best.
But when I got to use someone else's Sony, it just didn't quite feel right in the hand, kind of blocky - and in the pocket it felt very sort of wedged. Most concerningly given the price, the internet told a lot of stories of the screens being fragile, and same with the charging port covers on the Z3 (ugh why, even just the idea is annoying). I know some 'this phone is terrible!!' reviews are expected on any big product but it was out of proportion to other phones. Everyone was recommending protective cases but then we're back to now the phone is large again territory. Aargh.
In the end I thought I'd better not spend that kind of money on something I'm not totally sold on, and I might be better off getting a cheap second hand phone to tide me over until someone finally manufactures something I really want to buy, or the Compacts drop in price a bit more after a new release, or I just get less grumpy and resentful about the whole thing, but in any case
some kind of a phone was needed more or less immediately. So I took a meander through the second hand shops of the Cowley Road, picking up various models and nope-ing them all for one reason or another (well, OK, one of either 'too big' or 'too crap'). Until after about an hour of browsing, that magic moment I'd been hoping for happened. A phone caught my eye, I picked it up, and thought: yes, you. (*Probably, pending further research to make sure I'm not being stupid).
It turned out to be a
Galaxy S4 mini, which I vaguely remembered discarding from my original narrowing-down because buying a 2013 phone in 2016 felt like a stupid move given I want something that will last until like 2020 and surely phones just don't have that kind of life span. But using it in the shop it was perfectly snappy and felt good in the hand (124mm you guys, it's as good as it's likely to get). And having taken my expectations down from 'I'm going to buy the best!!' to 'I'm going to buy something good enough for now', the lower specs didn't upset me too much. I ended up getting one on Amazon because it was the same price the guy in the shop wanted for a good condition used one (£150). So hey, new phone after all, even if more sort of new-old-discount rather than top of the line new.
When it arrived it turned out not the original Galaxy S4 mini that was listed on the Amazon page (!), but actually an obscure Europe-only 2015 relaunch called the
S4 mini plus. Same form factor and components as the original but an improved chipset and newer Android installed. This actually turned out to be kind of annoying because no one seems to have written a way to root it that I could find. I spent pretty much an entire day getting all set up - backing up everything from my old one, cutting my old sim to size with kitchen scissors, and then finally getting the new one running just the way I want it (sadly sans root access). And it's good!
My review of my ~huge upgrade in life~ after 2 weeks of using it:
- The moar pixels and nice bright dust-free display is just lovely for all tasks. For the first day it was a kind of pleasant shock each time and now it's just like ahh, a background relief at everything being that little bit better.
- Things pretty much just work without me having to jiggerypoke it all with string and paperclips. I (obviously) don't mind doing so but it's still nice for things to be easy.
- Streaming music and podcasts is the single best new thing by far. I'm listening to a lot more stuff since it can arrive directly in my phone instead of my having to download it on my PC and transfer to the player by hand. I'm also doing less smartphone-zombie walking now I have reliable entertainment through the earphones.
- Animated gifs work now, mostly making my Twitter feed cuter.
- Being able to just Get An App For That (for most reasonable values of That) is very handy. Some small life admin conveniences are now possible, and some just fun additions, by which I mean Neko Atsume.
Honestly, it hasn't made as big a difference as I actually expected, more on the 'nice' than the 'mindblowing' end of the spectrum. It really reminds me that my old one did a surprisingly good-enough job on essentials (email, phone, texts, calendar, web browsing, etc) right up until it finally broke for good. I haven't used my shinier phone's shinier capabilities to leap out of social media lurkerdom or learn a new language or read a million books or take beautiful photographs or anything. That said I am certainly very grateful for the number of inconveniences removed and little bits of pleasantness added. I expect if I were to try to use my old phone now even in pre-totally-b0rked form I'd find it irritating and difficult, presumably increasingly so as the muscle memory of all the 'oh it's fine if you do it exactly like *this*' wears off.
Other thoughts:
- I was totally willing to pay moar money for moar better screen, camera etc but having got a comparatively cheap model, it's quite nice not being too worried about it re drops, scrapes, reading in the bath, etc.
- It's very thin, light (107g vs 129g for the Xperias), with very rounded corners, and the back is plastic, all of which add up to reviews calling its feel 'cheap'. But having wandered around handling them, it turns out I actually prefer that to the Xperias' heavier, 'premium', beautiful-featureless-metal-glass-slab feel. I don't really know why, it's probably a load of nonsense, but it makes it feel smaller almost, and less brittle (and even less constantly fingerprint-grimy). And I like that it's easy to open and get the battery out, next best thing to being fully waterproof really.
- Having rehashed all this, I find I'm still mildly resentful of having got a 'low spec' phone, if only for the future. I can only imagine in two years I'm probably going to find myself resetting app updates that want me to have a more up to date Android version or more processing power than I have, carefully clearing out old files from phone storage, and so on. But I'm well aware this is entirely my fault for being so behind the curve. On the other hand perhaps things are slowing and it won't get left behind as quickly? I am not nearly in touch enough with the state of phone tech to say. I am glad to see that it's a lot snappier than the Wildfire was even when it was new so maybe all will be well.
- Omg apps are so needy these days. Just because I have a notification bar that can fit more than two things at a time doesn't mean I want you all to immediately fill it up with pointless junk. A new Twitter message? Sure, let me know. 'Someone on Twitter posted something that got multiple likes!!', however, is NOT a moment I need to be informed of. And these cheeky buggers won't let you turn them off either. My screen real estate and time and attention are not free resource for you you jerks, and all you've achieved is getting me to disable ALL notifications from your app in the OS. ...OK I feel better now.
- As for the all-important pocketing, I'm here to report that yes, it fits... but honestly, only just. I have to rock it in gently at the right angle, and if I'm wearing tight jeans, or wearing a warm layer under my trousers, it's a noticeably awkward ritual that e.g. cannot be performed sitting down. But once it's in it's comfy for sitting or walking, and that's the important thing. In the end I'm glad it's not even a tiny bit bigger, although without a long term loan of another phone to test in real life conditions it's hard to say to what extent an extra 3mm or whatever would actually make a difference in reality.
- One handed use is at a similar point, i.e. technically manageable, but not always, and not totally comfortably. I actually really miss the joystick for comfortable and accurate one handed scrolling/selecting. Bring them back people, they're so underrated. I wonder if this is an unusual UI preference of mine, like preferring trackpoints to trackpads and keyboards to mice - I like it when I can use very minimal, fast and accurate gestures to control my device instead of needing my whole hand/arm.
In the end, in relation to my requirements, I'd say I compromised on requirement 1 to the minimum feasible, and on 3 more than I'd like. We'll have to see if it has as long and happy a life as its predecessor did, which would ultimately make all the compromises and imperfections worth it.
Writing it all, I clearly did a lot of research and considering and trying, but I can't help but think I probably just got the phone that presented itself IRL at about the point where I was receptive to buying the sort of thing that it is, if that makes sense. I suppose that's not a bad thing.
And maybe one day I'll get a phone that makes me go like <3_<3. Hey manufacturer R&D depts, along with making them small but powerful, can you also make them like, I dunno, matte textured, and maybe even slightly flexible? Thanks. I know I'm not asking for much. ;)